Quick extra time strike secures Northwest Christian’s first girls soccer title

extra time
The Northwest Christian soccer team celebrates after their 3A Championship game against Anthem Prep on Friday, Feb. 15 2019 at Williams Field High School in Gilbert. [Jacob Stanek/West Valley Preps]

Richard Smith
West Valley Preps

GILBERT – Following 80 uneven minutes of regulation, Northwest Christian needed to try something different in extra time.

Surprisingly, though it was the players – not the coaching staff – that called this audible. In a mere 11 seconds of overtime in the 3A girls soccer title game their play worked.

Freshman midfielder Makenzi Wisely took the kick off and  hit a through ball to sprinting senior defender Logan Maszton who blasted a low shot into the net for a 1-0 lead against Anthem Prep.

“They said, ‘Logan, you’re going to line up on the right and Makenzi, you’re going to trap it and send it and Logan you’re just going to run like the devil.’ We tried it one time before and it didn’t end up working,” Maszton said. “It was like a dream. We came up with it last second and just went with it.”

From there, No. 2 Northwest Christian (14-4) had to hold on for 20 minutes against the potent Eagles offense at Williams Field High School in Gilbert.

No. 5 Anthem Prep (13-3-1) produced a couple scares in the final six minutes of the second overtime. But the Crusaders clung to their 1-0 lead and claimed the first state title in program history.

“I am excited for them and the program. It is our first girls soccer state championship … ever. We’ve been to the finals three times,” Northwest Christian coach Jeff Penzone said.

Anthem Prep had a few more chances in the opening 30 minutes but neither team could really get untracked.

In the 37th minute Maszton nearly set up a goal with one of her trademark flipping throws but sophomore goalkeeper Ellie Colvig made a diving save of a rebound.

Thirteen seconds before half, an almost exact replica of that sequence happened.

“We had been doing this all year. We have a dynamic offense,” Anthem Prep Scott Gibbons. “We had our chances. Somebody’s got to lose right.”

Sporadic scoring chances broke up a cautious second half. A bobble from Crusaders sophomore goalkeeper Bethany Heater led to a nervous moment.

Northwest Christian nearly scored on a header in the 66th minute.

But the Crusaders rarely employed the high press that overwhelmed Fountain Hills in the Feb. 13 semifinal. Penzone said the offensive firepower of junior forward Olivia Friedman and senior flanks Brenna Pillsbury and Georgia Vallery led to more conservative tactics.

Friedman, in particular, required the attention of multiple defenders. In the final minute of regulation she created enough space for a near game-winner.

Pillsbury let fly from dead center of the box with 43 seconds left, only to see her shot fly inches over the crossbar

“It was pretty tense and we were all kind of stressed out. Once we got that goal, we relaxed and packed it in on defense,” Mastzon said.

During the five minute break before extra time Penzone talked mostly about effort.

He did not mention anything about trying a breakaway with his ace defender.

“The creativity in the first overtime when the goal was scored? I had no idea, Penzone said. “It was designed as a play. I just didn’t know they were running it. It was a lot of fun to watch.”

But the coach cannot imagine a more fitting player to score the title-winning goal.

Maszton is one of two Northwest Christian girls soccer seniors – along with forward Ana O’Neill. And she’s a mother hen of sorts to the team’s wave of young talent, which includes younger sister Lauren – a freshman.

“She’s the 3A player of the year. There is nobody that has come close to what she has done,” Penzone said. “She controls everything.”

Before they could celebrate, though, the Crusaders needed a savior. Anthem Prep built up for one more shot midway through the second 10 minutes of extra time.

Vallery aimed for the left side of the net but Heater leaped and knocked the shot down before smothering it on the turf.

“I said to myself, ‘You’ve got to stop this.’ I give all the glory to God because I had to make that save and I was in the right spot. After I saved that I thought, ‘Oh my gosh, we probably just won this,'” Heater said.

Anthem Prep made one frenzied rush in the last 30 seconds but could not produce a shot. Northwest Christian celebrated a trophy presentation decades in the making.

Penzone took over the program in the winter of 2014 after leading the Crusaders boys team to titles in 2010 and 2011 and a runner up finish to Scottsdale Coronado in 2014.

Before he was their coach, and during his tenure, the girls have always been a contender. But this was their first time in a state final since 2010.

“When the boys won their first I was head coach, so I’m fortunate to be first state title for the boys and first for the girls. We’re going to enjoy this for a bit,” Penzone said. “Getting back here and finishing it was a huge blessing for them. But they put in the work.”

Northwest Christian’s Makenzi Wisely attempts a shot on goal using her head during the 3A Championship game against Anthem Prep on Friday, Feb. 15 2019 at Williams Field High School in Gilbert. [Jacob Stanek/West Valley Preps]

You are encouraged to leave relevant comments but engaging in personal attacks, threats, online bullying or commercial spam will not be allowed. All comments should remain within the bounds of fair play and civility. (You can disagree with others courteously, without being disagreeable.) Feel free to express yourself but keep an open mind toward finding value in what others say. To report abuse or spam, click the X in the upper right corner of the comment box.